Abstract
In this population-level study, we analyzed how well changes in drug and alcohol use among homicide victims explained declining homicide rates in New York City between 1990 and 1998. Victim demographics, cause of death, and toxicology were obtained for all homicide (N = 12573) and accidental death victims (N = 6351) between 1990 and 1998 from the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner of New York (OCME). The proportion of homicide and accident decedents positive for cocaine fell between 1990 and 1998 (13% and 9% respectively); the proportion of homicide and accident decedents positive for opiates and/or alcohol did not change significantly. Changing patterns of drug and alcohol use by homicide victims were comparable to changing patterns of drug and alcohol use in accident victims, suggesting that changes in drug and alcohol use among homicide victims between 1990 and 1998 cannot solely explain the decline in NYC homicide rates.
Issue Section:
Research Papers
References
1.
Helmuth
L
. Has America's tide of violence receded for good?
Science
0036-8075 2000
;289
:582
–5
.2.
Federal Bureau of Investigation
. Crime in the United States: Annual Uniform Crime Reports
. Washington (DC): Department of Justice
, 1990–1999.3.
Cyrus
S
, Guahua
L
. Homicide mortality in the US, 1935–1994: Age, period, and cohort effects
. Am J Epidemiol
0002-9262 1999
;150
:1213
–22
.4.
Spunt
B
, Goldstein
P
, Brownstein
H
, Fendrich
M
, and Langley
S
. Alcohol and homicide: Interviews with prison inmates
. J Drug Issues
1994
;24
:143
–63
.5.
Spunt
B
, Brownstein
H
, Goldstein
P
, Fendrich
M
, Liberty
HJ
. Drug use by homicide offenders
. J Psychoactive Drugs
0279-1072 1995
;27
:125
–34
.6.
Haberman
P
, Baden
M
. Alcohol, other drugs and violent death
. New York
: Oxford University Press
, 1978
.7.
Kratcoski
PC
. Circumstances surrounding homicides by older offenders
. Crim Justic Behav
1990
;17
:420
–30
.8.
Wieczorek
WF
, Welte
JW
, Abel
EL
. Alcohol, drugs and murder: A study of convicted homicide offenders
. J Crim Justice
1990
;18
:217
–27
.9.
Tardiff
K
, Marzuk
PM
, Leon
AC
, Hirsch
CS
, Stajic
M
, Porter
L
, Hartwell
N
. Cocaine, opiates and ethanol in homicides in New York City: 1990 and 1991
. J Forensic Sci
0022-1198 1995
;40
:387
–90
.10.
Hanzlick
R
, Gowitt
GT
. Cocaine metabolite detection in homicide victims
. JAMA
0098-7484 1991
;26
:760
–61
.11.
Garriott
JC
. Drug use among homicide victims: Changing patterns
. Am J Forensic Med Path
0195-7910 1993
;14
:234
–37
.12.
Rogers
JN
, Henry
TE
, Jones
AM
, Froede
RC
, Byers
JM
. Cocaine-related deaths in Prima County Arizona, 1982–1984
. J Forensic Sci
0022-1198 1986
;31
:1404
–8
.13.
Tardiff
K
, Marzuk
PM
, Leon
AC
, Hirsch
CS
, Portera
L
. Homicide in New York City: Cocaine and firearms
. JAMA
0098-7484 1994
;272
:43
–6
.14.
National Institute on Drug Abuse
. National household survey on drug abuse: Main findings 1991
. 1993
U.S. Dept. of Mental Health and Human Services Publication S.M.A.
93–1980.15.
Goldstein
PJ
, Brownstein
HH
, Ryan
PJ
, Bellucci
PA
. Crack and homicide in New York City, 1988: A conceptually based event analysis
. Contemp Drug Problems
1989
;16
:652
–87
.16.
Tardiff
K
, Marzuk
PM
, Lowell
K
, Portera
L
, Leon
AC
. A study of drug abuse and other causes of homicide in New York
. J Crim Justice
2002
;30
:125
–34
.17.
Bureau of the Census
. Census summary tape, file 3A (STF3A)
. Washington (DC): US Department of Commerce
, 1990
and 2000
.18.
Office of Management Analysis and Planning
. The Compstat Process
. New York (NY)
: The New York City Police Department
(No. BM 754), 1997
.19.
Bratton
W
. Crime is down in New York City: Blame the police
. In: Dennis
N
, editor. Zero tolerance: Policing a free society
. London
: Institute of Economic Affairs
, 1997
.20.
Bratton
W
, Knobler
. Turnaround: How America's top cop reversed the crime epidemic
. New York: Random House
, 1998
.21.
Gorta
B
. Zero tolerance—The real story or the hidden lessons of New York
. Police Research and Management
1998
;Winter:15
–21
.22.
Bowling
B
. The rise and fall of New York murder
. Brit J Criminol
1999
;39
:531
–54
.23.
Kelling
GL
, Coles
CM
. Fixing broken windows: Restoring order and reducing crime in our communities
. New York
: Simon and Schuster
, 1996
.24.
Hamid
A
. The developmental cycle of a drug epidemic: The cocaine smoking epidemic of 1981–1991
. J Psychoactive Drugs
0279-1072 1992
;4
:337
–48
.25.
Golub
A
, Johnson
B
. A recent decline in cocaine use among youthful arrestees in Manhattan, 1987 through 1993
. Am J Public Health
0090-0036 1994
;84
:1250–4.24.26.
Manschreck
TC
, Laughery
J
, Weisstein
CC
, Allen
D
, Humblestone
B
, Neville
M
, Podlewski
H
, Mitra
N
. Characteristics of freebase cocaine psychosis
. Yale J Biol Med
0044-0086 1988
;61
:115
–22
.27.
Blumstein
A
, Rivara
FP
, Rosenfeld
R
. The rise and decline of homicide—and why
. Annu Rev Public Health
0163-7525 2000
;21
:505
–41
.
This content is only available via PDF.
Copyright © 2005 by ASTM
You do not currently have access to this content.
