Abstract

This paper reports a bilaterally symmetrical cranio-facial fracture pattern that is observed in self-inflicted, midline gunshot wounds. Five cases of self-inflicted gunshots wounds are presented as follows: two high-powered rifle cases, two shotgun cases, and one handgun case. In all five cases the remains were either decomposing or skeletonized and submitted to forensic anthropologists. Following identification, the main focus of the anthropological examination was the analysis of perimortem trauma to the skeleton. In each case, the skull was submitted in a highly fragmented state. Nevertheless, by focusing on the pattern of perimortem cranio-facial fractures, the anthropologists contributed key information regarding the circumstances of death. The observed symmetrical cranio-facial fracture patterns in the above cases are described in detail and interpreted. The specific location of the linear fractures is discussed, as well as the theoretical rationale behind the location in terms of skeletal architecture, such as buttresses, struts, and sutures. The interpretive framework provided by this paper may prove helpful to others who are faced with similar cases of cranio-facial fracturing.

References

1.
Avis
SP
.
Suicidal gunshot wounds
.
Forensic Sci Int
 0379-0738
1994
;
67
:
41
7
.
2.
Di Maio
VJM
.
Gunshot wounds: practical aspects of firearms, ballistics, and forensic techniques
. 2nd ed.
Boca Raton
:
CRC Press
,
1999
.
3.
Sauer
NJ
.
The timing of injuries and manner of death: distinguishing among antemortem, perimortem, and postmortem trauma
. In:
Reichs
KJ
, editor.
Forensic osteology: advances in the identification of human remains
.
Springfield
:
Charles C Thomas
,
1998
;
321
32
.
4.
Galloway
A
,
Symes
SA
,
Haglund
WD
,
France
DL
.
The role of the forensic anthropologist in trauma analysis
. In:
Galloway
A
, editor.
Broken bones: anthropological analysis of blunt force trauma
.
Springfield
:
Charles C Thomas
,
1999
;
5
31
.
5.
Fenton
TW
,
deJong
JL
,
Haut
RC
.
Punched with a fist: the etiology of a fatal depressed cranial fracture
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
2003
;
48
:
277
81
.
6.
Spitz
WU
.
Injury by gunfire
. In:
Spitz
WU
, editor.
Medicolegal investigation of death: guidelines for the application of pathology to crime investigation
. 3rd ed.
Springfield
:
Charles C Thomas
,
1993
;
311
412
.
7.
Berryman
HE
,
Symes
SA
.
Recognizing gunshot and blunt cranial trauma through fracture interpretation
. In:
Reichs
KJ
, editor.
Forensic osteology: advances in the identification of human remains
.
Springfield
:
Charles C Thomas
,
1998
;
333
52
.
8.
Dixon
DS
.
Gunshot wounds: forensic implications in a surgical practice
. In:
Ordog
GJ
, editor.
Management of gunshot wounds
.
New York
:
Elsevier
,
1988
;
167
86
.
9.
Coe
JI
.
External beveling of entrance wounds by handgun
.
Am J Forensic Med Pathol
 0195-7910
1982
;
3
:
215
9
.
10.
Baik
S-O
,
Uku
JM
,
Sikirica
M
.
A case of external beveling with an entrance gunshot wound to the skull made by a small caliber rifle bullet
.
Am J Forensic Med Pathol
 0195-7910
1991
;
12
:
334
6
.
11.
Peterson
BL
.
External beveling of cranial gunshot entrance wounds
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
1991
;
36
:
1592
5
.
12.
Smith
OC
,
Berryman
HE
,
Lahren
CH
.
Cranial fracture patterns and estimate of direction from low velocity gunshot wounds
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
1987
;
32
:
1416
2
13.
Gonzales
TA
,
Vance
M
,
Helpern
M
,
Umberger
CJ
.
Legal medicine pathology and toxicology
. 2nd ed.
New York
:
Appleton-Century-Crofts Inc.
,
1954
.
14.
Stefan
VH
.
Symmetrical radiating fractures resulting from cranial gunshot wounds [abstract]
.
Proceedings of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences
; 1999 Feb 15–20;
Orlando (FL)
.
Colorado Springs
:
American Academy of Forensic Sciences
,
1999
;216.
15.
Galloway
A
.
Fracture patterns and skeletal morphology: introduction and the skull
. In:
Galloway
A
, editor.
Broken bones: anthropological analysis of blunt force trauma
.
Springfield
:
Charles C Thomas
,
1999
;
63
80
.
16.
Le Count
ER
,
Hockzema
J
.
Symmetrical traumatic fractures of the cranium; symmetrical fragmentation
.
Arch Surg
1934
;
29
:
171
226
.
17.
Rogers
LF
.
Radiology of skeletal trauma
.
New York
:
Churchill Livingstone
,
1982
.
18.
Knight
B
.
Forensic pathology
.
London
:
Edward Arnold
,
1991
.
19.
Gurdjian
ES
,
Gonzales
D
,
Hodgson
VR
,
Thomas
LM
,
Greenberg
SW
.
Comparisons of research in inanimate and biological material: artifacts and pitfalls
. In:
Gurdjian
ES
,
Lange
WA
,
Patrick
LM
,
Thomas
LM
, editors.
Impact injury and crash protection
.
Springfield
:
Charles C Thomas
,
1970
;
234
55
.
20.
Gurdjian
ES
,
Webster
JE
,
Lissner
HR
.
Observations on Predictions of Fracture Site in Head Injury
.
Radiology
 0033-8419
1953
;
60
:
226
35
.
21.
Gurdjian
ES
,
Lissner
HR
.
Deformation of the skull in head injury: a study with the “stresscoat” technique
.
Surgery, Gynecology, and Obstetrics
 0039-6087
1945
;
81
:
679
87
.
22.
Gurdjian
ES
,
Lissner
HR
,
Webster
JE
.
The mechanism of production of linear skull fractures
.
Surgery, Gynecology, and Obstetrics
 0039-6087
1947
;
85
:
195
210
.
23.
Gurdjian
ES
,
Webster
JE
,
Lissner
HR
.
The mechanism of skull fracture
.
Radiology
 0033-8419
1950
;
54
:
313
38
.
24.
Galloway
A
.
Biomechanics of fracture production
. In:
Galloway
A
, editor.
Broken bones: anthropological analysis of blunt force trauma
.
Springfield
:
Charles C Thomas
,
1999
;
35
62
.
25.
Kroman
AM
.
Experimental study of fracture propagation in the human skull: a re-testing of popular theories
.
Proceedings of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences
, 2004 Feb. 16–21
Dallas, TX
.
Colorad Spring
:
American Academy of Forensic Sciences
,
2004
.
26.
Gurdjian
ES
,
Lissner
HR
,
Hodgson
VR
, et al
Mechanisms at head injury
.
Clin Neurosurg
 0069-4827
1966
;
12
:
112
28
.
27.
Seelig
JM
,
Marshall
LF
.
Biomechanics of head injury: clinical aspects
. In:
Nahum
AM
,
Melvin
J
, editors.
Biomechanics of Trauma
.
Norwalk
:
Appleton-Century-Crofts
,
1985
.
28.
Nahum
AM
,
Gatts
JD
,
Godd
CW
,
Danforth
JP
.
Impact tolerance of the face and skull
.
Proceedings of the 12th Stapp Car Crash Conference
,
1968
.
New York
:
Society of Automotive Engineers
,
1968
.
29.
Schneider
DC
,
Nahum
AM
.
Impact studies of facial bones and skull
.
Proceedings of the 16th Stapp Car Crash Conference
,
1972
.
New York
:
Society of Automotive Engineers
,
1972
.
30.
Allsop
DL
.
Human facial fracture and compliance [doctoral dissertation]
. Provo (UT):
Brigham Young University
,
1989
.
31.
Vance
BM
.
Fractures of the skull
.
Arch Surg
1927
;
14
:
1023
91
.
32.
Gotzen
N
,
Cross
AR
,
Ifju
PG
,
Rapoff
AJ
.
Understanding stress concentration about a nutrient foramen
.
Journal Biomechanics
 0021-9290
2003
;
36
:
1511
21
.
33.
LeCount
ER
,
Apfelbach
CW
.
Pathologic anatomy of traumatic fractures of the cranial bones and concomitant brain injuries
.
JAMA
 0098-7484
1920
;
74
:
501
11
.
34.
Gentry
LR
,
Manor
WF
,
Turski
PA
,
Strother
CM
.
High-resolution CT analysis of facial struts in trauma: 2. Normal anatomy
.
Am J of Roentgenology
 0092-5381
1983
;
140
:
523
32
.
35.
Moritz
AR
.
The pathology of trauma
. 2nd rev. ed.
Philadelphia
:
Lea & Febiger
,
1954
.
36.
Le Fort
R
.
Etude experimentale sur les fractures de la machoire superieure
. Revue de Chirurgie
1901
.
37.
Dempster
WT
.
The grain of cortical bone in relation to structural features of the adult skull
.
Seventy-eighth Session of the American Association of Anatomists
; 1965 April 20–23,
Miami (FL)
:
University of Miami School of Medicine
,
Miami
,
1965
;
151
:
342
3
.
38.
Tappen
NC
.
Main patterns and individual differences in baboon skull split-lines and theories of causes of split-line orientation in bone
.
Am J Phys Anthropol
 0002-9483
1970
;
33
:
61
71
.
39.
Benninghoff
A
.
Spaltlinien am knochen, eine methode zur ermittlung der architektur platter knochen
.
Verhandl Anat Gesellsch
 0066-1562
1925
;
34
:
189
206
.
40.
Benninghoff
A
,
Göerttler
K
.
Lehrbuch der Anatomie des Menschen
. München,
1957
.
41.
Tappen
NC
.
A functional analysis of the facial skeleton with split-line technique
.
Am J Phys Anthropol
 0002-9483
1953
;
11
:
503
32
.
42.
Tappen
NC
.
A comparative functional analysis of primate skulls by the split-line technique
.
Hum Biol
 0018-7143
1954
;
26
:
221
38
.
43.
Tappen
NC
.
An examination of alternative explanations of split-line orientation in compact bone
.
Am J Phys Anthropol
 0002-9483
1964
;
22
:
423
42
.
44.
Ordog
GJ
.
Wound Ballistics
. In:
Ordog
GJ
, editor.
Management of gunshot wounds
.
New York
:
Elsevier
,
1988
;
25
60
.
45.
Aiello
L
,
Dean
C
.
An introduction to human evolutionary anatomy
.
London
:
Academic Press
,
1990
.
This content is only available via PDF.
You do not currently have access to this content.