Abstract

Misidentification of people may occur in a number of psychiatric disorders associated with delusional thinking. Misidentification of people may also occur in the context of visual flashback phenomena associated with post-traumatic stress disorder. People who misidentify someone during a flashback associated with previous war combat experience may perceive and conceptualize the misidentified object as an enemy who may be both feared and disliked. This might make the misidentified objects become the targets of violent attacks by the affected person. In this article we present five cases of flashback-induced misidentification of people who were subsequently attacked within the context of the flashback experience. The nature of the misidentification of persons due to flashback experiences is discussed. The association between the type of misidentification and aggression is also discussed.

References

1.
Loftus
E F
.
Eyewitness testimony
.
Harvard University Press
,
Cambridge, MA
,
1979
.
2.
Silva
J A
,
Leong
G B
,
Shaner
A L
.
A classification system for misidentification syndromes
.
Psychopathology
 0254-4962
1990
;
23
:
27
-
32
.
3.
Fishbain
D A
.
The frequency of Capgras delusions in a psychiatric emergency service
.
Psychopathology
 0254-4962
1987
;
20
:
42
-
7
.
4.
de Pauw
K W
,
Szulecka
T F
.
Dangerous delusions: violence and the misidentification syndromes
.
Br J Psychiatry
1988
;
152
:
91
-
6
.
5.
Silva
J A
,
Leong
G B
,
Weinstock
R
.
The dangerousness of persons with misidentification syndromes
.
Bull Am Acad Psychiatry Law
1992
;
20
:
77
-
86
.
6.
Silva
J A
,
Leong
G B
,
Weinstock
R
,
Klein
R L
.
Psychiatric factors associated with dangerous misidentification delusions
.
Bull Am Acad Psychiatry Law
1995
;
23
:
53
-
61
.
7.
Nestor
P G
,
Haycock
J
,
Doiron
S
,
Kelly
J
,
Kelly
D
.
Lethal violence and psychosis in clinical profile
.
Bull Am Acad Psychiatry Law
1995
;
23
:
231
-
341
.
8.
Sparr
L F
,
Reaves
M E
,
Atkinson
R M
.
Military combat, posttraumatic stress diorder, and criminal behavior in Vietnam veterans
.
Bull Am Acad Psychiatry Law
1987
;
15
:
141
-
62
.
9.
Lasko
N B
,
Gurvits
,
T V
,
Kuhne
A A
,
Orr
S P
,
Pitman
R K
.
Aggression and its correlates in Vietnam veterans with and without chronic posttraumatic stress disorder
.
Compr Psychiatry
 0010-440X
1994
;
35
:
373
-
81
.
10.
Sparr
L F
,
Moffitt
M C
.
Forensic issues associated with posttraumatic stress disorder
. In:
Schlesinger
L B
, editor.
Explorations in criminal psychopathology: Clinical syndromes with forensic implications
.
Charles C Thomas
,
Springfield, IL
,
1996
:
274
-
99
.
11.
American Psychiatric Association
.
Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders
, 4th Edition.
American Psychiatric Association
,
Washington, DC
,
1994
.
12.
American Psychiatric Association
.
Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders
, 3rd Edition.
American Psychiatric Association
,
Washington, DC
,
1980
.
13.
Spiegel
D
,
Hunt
T
,
Dondershine
H E
.
Dissociation and hypnotizability in posttraumatic stress disorder
.
Am J Psychiatry
1988
;
145
:
301
-
5
.
14.
Spiegel
D
,
Spiegel
H
.
Trance and treatment: Clinicl uses of hypnosis
.
American Psychiatric Press
,
Washington, DC
,
1987
.
15.
Mott
T
.
The clinical importance of hypnotizability
.
Am J Clin Hypnosis
1979
;
21
:
263
-
9
.
16.
Putnam
F W
,
Carlson
E B
,
Ross
C A
,
Anderson
G
,
Clark
P
,
Torem
M
, et al
Patterns of dissociation in clinical and nonclinical samples
.
J Nervous and Mental Disease
1996
;
184
:
673
-
9
.
17.
Davidson
J RT
,
March
J S
.
Traumatic stress disorders
. In:
Tasman
A
,
Kay
J
,
Lieberman
J A
, editors.
Psychiatry
, Volume
2
.
W.B. Saunders Company
,
Philadelphia
,
1997
;
1085
-
99
.
18.
Kardiner
A
.
The traumatic neurosis of war
.
Basic Books
,
New York
,
1941
.
19.
Grinker
R
,
Spiegel
J
.
Men under stress
.
Blakiston
,
Philadelphia
,
1945
.
20.
Hendin
H
,
Haas
A P
.
Wounds of war: The psychological aftermath of combat in Vietnam
.
Basic Books
,
New York
,
1984
.
21.
Feldmann
T B
.
Violence as a disintegrative product of the self in posttraumatic stress disorder
.
Am J Psychotherapy
1988
;
42
:
281
-
9
.
22.
Stone
A A
.
Posttraumatic stress disorder and the law: critical review of the new frontier
.
Bull Am Acad Psychiatry Law
1993
;
21
:
23
-
6
.
23.
Sparr
L F
.
Mental defenses and posttraumatic stress disorder: assessment of criminal intent
.
J Traumatic Stress
1996
;
405
-
25
.
24.
Appelbaum
P S
,
Jick
R Z
,
Grisso
T
,
Giveber
D
,
Silver
E
,
Steadman
H J
.
Use of posttraumatic stress disorder to support an insanity defense
.
Am J Psychiatry
1993
;
150
:
229
-
34
.
25.
Slovenko
R
.
Legal aspects of post-traumatic stress disorder
.
Psychiatr Clin No Amer
1994
;
17
:
439
-
46
.
26.
Sparr
L
,
Pankratz
L D
.
Factitious posttraumatic stress disorder
.
Am J Psychiatry
1983
;
140
:
1016
-
19
.
27.
Colbach
E M
.
The post-Vietnam stress syndrome: some cautions
.
Bull Am Acad Psychiatry Law
1985
;
13
:
369
-
72
.
28.
Blank
A S
.
The unconscious flashback in Vietnam veterans: clinical mystery, legal defense, and community problem
. In:
Sonnenberg
S M
,
Blank
A S
,
Talbott
J A
, editors.
The trauma of war: Stress and recovery in Vietnam veterans
.
American Psychiatric Press
,
Washington, DC
,
1985
;
293
-
308
.
This content is only available via PDF.
You do not currently have access to this content.